The Very Best of Friends
By Margaret Wild
The Very Best of Friends is about the relationship between a cat named William and a woman named Jesse. At the beginning of the story the two live on a farm with a man named James, who is quite fond of William while Jesse is not. Then James dies, Jesse distances herself further from William and kicks him out. After some time passes, she changes her mind and begins to grow closer to William. William forgives her and the two become friends.
Guidelines for Philosophical Discussion
By Sara Rodriguez
The Very Best of Friends could be used to provoke a philosophical discussion about the ethics surrounding the treatment of animals. In the book, James treats the cat William as if he is a good friend, as do many families. Humans often treat their beloved pets as if they are miniature people, yet we allow other animals to be slaughtered for food. How should we resolve the apparent inconsistency in understanding of our relationship with animals? In children’s books especially, animals are personified quite frequently which suggests that they are the same as humans, having similar rights. However, others think that humans are superior to animals and can use animals for their own purposes whether it be for companionship, food, or clothing. Even if humans are superior, do animals still deserve the same level of respect and compassion that we award other humans?
Questions for Philosophical Discussion