Recent Changes - Search:

Beauty and the Beast

By Teddy Slater

Summary

An enchantress curses a prince by turning him into a hideous Beast and his servants into household items after he refuses to shelter her in his castle in exchange for a rose. In order to break the spell, the Beast must find someone to love him before the last petal falls off the rose.

In a nearby village lives a young woman named Belle whose father is an inventor. Belle’s father Maurice becomes lost on his way to sell his inventions at the market and is taken captive inside the Beast’s castle. After Maurice’s horse returns to the village, Belle heads towards the Beast’s castle and offers to take Maurice’s position, to which the Beast agrees. Belle and the Beast become close while Maurice is unable to convince the townsfolk to rescue Belle from the castle.

Belle sees Maurice’s situation from the Beast’s magic mirror and is able to leave the castle to help him. A villager named Gaston, who loves Belle purely for her looks, agrees to confront the Beast. At the castle, Gaston and the Beast engage in a fight that ends with Gaston stabbing the Beast in the back and falling off the tall castle wall. Belle is saddened by the Beast’s defeat and proclaims her love towards him, after which the Beast reverts to his princely form and the two live happily ever after.

Guidelines for Philosophical Discussion

By Samuel Diaz de Leon and Angel Villa

Beauty and the Beast immediately raises questions about punishment. To begin the story, an enchantress curses a prince who does not provide her shelter in exchange for a rose. The punishment that she metes out is such that the prince turns into a hideous Beast, and until he learns to love someone and earn their love in return, will the curse be broken. Moreover, the servants of the prince’s castle are all turned into pieces of furniture and decor. The curse will become irreversible after the falling of the rose’s last petal. This instance of punishment may seem odd for a variety of reasons. For starters, one could question whether or not the enchantress carries the appropriate authority to give out such a punishment. Secondly, the punishment seems a bit overboard. After all, it is not obvious that the prince was obligated to provide shelter for the enchantress, and even if he was, the curse that she placed on him and his servants lest we forget is much harsher than the night she would have spent outside in the storm.

To the first point raised, many have the conception that punishment should come from a proper authority such as one’s parents or the government, but why can’t it be the case that a person of equal standing should be charged with administering punishment as well? In the case of the enchantress, it might seem obvious that she has special powers that no one else seems to have; these powers also seem to be unbeatable. Thus, most children would probably come to the conclusion that the enchantress has the proper authority. But what about parents punishing their children, or brothers and sisters or friends punishing each other, should they be able to administer punishment as well? What makes someone worthy of administering punishment?

The second point raised a question about the severity of the enchantress’s punishment on the prince and his servants. Mainly, how should one carry out punishment and why? As was mentioned before, the punishment seems harsh. This was definitely not an “eye for an eye” punishment where the enchantress would have locked the prince outside of his castle in the cold rain. It was worse than that! But, maybe the enchantress had good reason for such a severe punishment. Recall, that the enchantress saw that the “[Prince] had no love in his heart.” Perhaps the utter lack of love in one’s heart is so much of an egregious sin as to warrant such a damning punishment not only for oneself but to his servants as well. Maybe, maybe not. Furthermore, the enchantress might have thought that her punishment would change the prince and bring about the greater good (which it did). Maybe the enchantress also wanted to deter any of the servants from acting like their prince. But, do any of these reasons make the enchantress’s punishment justified? This could be boiled down to: when is it okay to punish someone, and how harsh should the punishment be?

Another interesting issue raised by the events in the story is coercion. One instance of coercion in the story is when Gaston plots to put Maurice in an insane asylum unless Belle agrees to marry him. Gaston’s proposition to Belle has two potential consequences; one in which Gaston gets the marriage he wants and Belle’s father is kept away from the unwanted insane asylum, and another in which Gaston doesn’t get the marriage and Belle’s father is sent away. It may seem that the first outcome is favorable for both Gaston and Belle in this situation; however, this is only possible because Gaston is using Maurice’s imprisonment in the asylum as a threat. The choice Gaston gives to Belle is: Marry me or your father goes to the asylum.

Most would hopefully say that Gaston’s offer is not fair. However, if the circumstances were different and Maurice was not heading off to the asylum, would it be fair if Gaston instead offered Belle one million dollars to marry him? Is this coercion? What makes the two offers different from each other?

Questions for Philosophical Discussion

Punishment

  1. What makes someone worthy of carrying out punishment?
  2. Why did the enchantress punish the prince? Did he deserve the punishment?
  3. Was the punishment the prince received too harsh? Why?
  4. When is it ok for someone to be punished?
  5. What should be the goals of punishment?
  6. How harsh should the punishment be?

Coercion

  1. How did Gaston try to get Belle to marry him? Did it work? Is this okay? Why or why not?
  2. What if Gaston instead offered Belle one million dollars for her hand in marriage instead of sending her father off to the asylum? Is this okay? Why? What makes the last offer different from this offer?
  3. Why do we try to get people to do things?
  4. When is it wrong to try to get people to do things? Is it ever right or necessary?

This book module deals with Punishment and Coercion. You can buy this book on Amazon.

Creative Commons License This website was developed with the assistance of the Squire Family Foundation.