Author: Jon J. Muth
Publisher: Scholastic Press
Stillwater the panda moves into the house on the hill and shares valuable lessons with his new friends through classic Zen stories designed to challenge our perspective on our own lives through emotions such as anger, worrying and jealousy.
Guidelines for Philosophical Discussion
Zen Shorts is the story of how Stillwater the panda becomes friends with three kids Addy, Michael and Karl. Stillwater teaches each child lessons through stories that help them handle the events in their lives. When Stillwater shares the story of Uncle Ry and the Moon he parallels the idea of unselfish giving with the tale of a simple man who was one day visited by a robber. Instead of disturbing the robber he welcomes him into his home and gives him his only robe as a gift. Instead of feeling sorry for himself with nothing left to wear, Uncle Ry instead feels remorse for not being able to give away something as beautiful as the moon. This raises questions such as the value of material things and their role in our lives. What do we value most? What do we value least? Are the most valuable things in our lives material? The Uncle does not place value in material things but instead in people and interaction with them. This questions the idea that while some material objects are necessary to our survival what objects are really necessary for happiness? It also puts into perspective the relationships in our lives. Uncle Ry doesn’t consider the robber as a threat because he places no value in his possessions. He instead views the opportunity as a chance to build a new relationship which for him is far more valuable than his robe. This may suggest that happiness is best achieved without material things. Often we focus on acquiring material things in order to be happier, but this story suggests that the less we value material objects the happier we can be. Nobody can take objects that are not material, and so nobody can take away our happiness if it is not dependent on material objects. He instead views the opportunity as a chance to build a new relationship which for him is far more valuable than his robe.
Michael and Stillwater discuss how we interpret events in our lives and the effect this can have on our happiness. Stillwater’s tale The Farmers Luck tells the story of a farmer whose neighbours are always ready to accept his bad luck. After each negative encounter they shake their heads and wish him better luck. The farmer does not waste any time worrying over the bad luck and simple answers “maybe” after each comment. In the end what the neighbours thought was bad luck turned out to be incredibly good luck and instead of wasting his time worrying the farmer instead accepted the events at hand in order to make the most of them. This brings into question how our perspective on events affect our happiness. In refusing to allow his supposed bad luck to ruin his day, the farmer avoids unhappiness. This suggests that perhaps it is not luck that matters but rather how we respond to it. Let’s take a look at an example: A person getting a flat tire may consider it bad luck perhaps it makes him late for work. But if we later learn that by getting the flat tire that person avoided a disaster by being a few minutes late then we would think of him as being very lucky. In accepting the events at hand and dealing with them in the best manner possible the farmer is able to see and appreciate the good luck in his life without overshadowing it with the negative. Luck is not what matters but rather our response to the events around us.
Karl visits Michael and is angry for telling him not to bring so many pool toys to visit Stillwater. While they play in the pool Stillwater tells the story of two monks. One carries a young woman across a stream and when she doesn’t thank him the other monk becomes angry. They come to the conclusion that the young monk was angry over nothing because the older monk was unburdened by the events and the young monk was letting them ruin his day despite the fact that they were long since over. Karl realized that since he was so angry at Michael he hadn’t noticed how much fun they were having in the pool, and that Michael had been right about him bringing too many pool toys. Karl had let his anger ruin his day of fun and he has also missed valuable advice from his brother by holding onto his anger. This story examines the importance letting go of anger. In not letting the lady anger him, the older monk was better able to enjoy the remainder of his day while the younger monk suffered needlessly by carrying his anger. This story asks us to question the role of anger in our lives and if it’s really worth its weight. It shows how destructive anger can be and how much happier we are if we learn to let it go.
Questions for Philosophical Discussion
- The value of generosity:
- Why wasn’t Uncle Ry angry with the robbing raccoon?
- Why do you think uncle Ry gave away his only robe?
- In the story Uncle Ry feels bad about giving the robber his robe, why do you think this is?
- How do you think the robber felt when Uncle Ry welcomed him into his home?
- Who was generous in the story?
- Think of a time when you were generous (split up into small groups and share examples)
- Think of a time when someone did something generous for you (in the same small groups share your examples)
- What does it mean to be generous?
- Why is it sometimes hard to be generous?
- Why do we do generous acts?
- The importance of sharing:
- What are some of the things the Children share with Stillwater in the story?
- What is an example of a time someone shared with you? How did this make you feel? (split up and talk about it in small groups)
- Who do you share with?
- Why do you think sharing is important?
- How would society be if no one shared?
- Perspectives of luck:
- Why was the farmer lucky that his horse had run away?
- Why was the son lucky to have broken his leg?
- When is a time that you have felt lucky?
- What is an example of a time you felt unlucky? How was this different from feeling lucky?
- What do you do when you feel unlucky?
- In groups give an example of a time when you felt unlucky but as time passed realized that you were actually lucky.
- Do you know anyone that has bad luck but is still happy?
- Do you know anyone that had bad luck but is still successful?
- Do you think having good luck is necessary to being successful?
- If luck is not necessary to being successful than what is?
- The weight of anger:
- How does Karl feel about Michael telling him what to do?
- What does he do while he is angry with Michael?
- Why do you think Michael was telling Karl what to do?
- How did the older Monk feel after carrying the young woman across the water?
- How did the younger Monk feel after they left?
- Why do you think the Older Monk was unaffected by how the young woman treated him?
- What does an angry person look like? (make an angry face)
- What does someone who is angry but not showing it look like?
- When is a time you have felt really angry?
- When did you start to feel better?
- Do you know anyone that seems to never get angry? Do you know anyone that always seems angry? Which of those people seem happier?
- The meaning of friendship:
- How does Stillwater help Addy, Karl and Michael?
- How do you treat your friends?
- How does your best friend treat you? How do you expect to be treated by your best friend?
- What do you think it means to be a good friend?
- What can you learn from your friends?