Little Blue and Little Yellow
Author: Leo Lionni
Publisher: Alfred A. Knopf (New York)
by Hina Jawaid
‘Little blue’ instead of staying at home went out looking for his friend ‘little yellow’. They played together, had a lot of fun and ended by looking like little green. When this happened their parents couldn't recognize them. The story is a journey in which the parents of ‘little blue’ and ‘little yellow’ and the readers realize what actually happened.
Guidelines for Philosophical Discussion
by Hina Jawaid, with additions by Thomas Wartenberg
Leo Lionni’s seemingly simple “Little Blue and Little Yellow” is packed with philosophical content and raises questions about multiple philosophical issues. While all the parts are interconnected and overlapping I have divided the questions thematically into 3 parts. Each part addresses a distinct concept in philosophy: friendship, knowledge, identity and the material constitution of things. You can talk about any or all of them.
When little blue and little yellow hug each other they merge into little green. Since they are best friends, their new color represents a merging of their two individual colors. This raises the question of what a friendship is like. Do friends have to become completely like each other to be good friends? If not, then what do they have to have in common to be friends? Can you be friends with someone with whom you share no common interest? Is a person who is really different from you actually a better candidate for friendship because their difference will provide lots of interesting things to discuss? This can then lead into a more abstract discussion of whether and why a person needs friends in her life. Or could a person lead a fulfilled life even if she had no friends? These are significant philosophical issues that also play a crucial role in children's lives.
In epistemology (the study of knowledge) knowledge is classified as justified true belief. The story brings up the basic yet important issue of the nature of our beliefs and how new information impacts our beliefs. When the parents assert that little green is not ‘Little Blue’ they exhibit their belief about their child. This begs the question: is their belief justified and true? That is: did mama and papa blue have the knowledge that green was not ‘Little Blue’? Most philosophers would argue that this was simply a belief which was not true or justified. Epistemology tries to understand how we know the things we know. Additionally, it tries to ensure that the things we know are true because otherwise they are just beliefs. For example the book raises the question of whether is it true that green is not ‘Little Blue’? Lionni leaves the decision to the reader. Additionally the beliefs we hold are molded by the information we have. The book displays this concept: once the parents hugged and witnessed what happened they understand better. The acquisition of new information can have an impact and can change our beliefs.
The formation of little green raises questions about the next philosophical concept. That is: what things are made up of. Metaphysics, the study of the nature of reality deals with this issue of material constitution. Philosophers are divided in their views on this topic. Some believe that parts are more important than the whole. I will explain this by using a simple example. When you make vegetable soup, the constituents are the vegetables and the broth. The soup is simply a different form of the two put together. This illustrates that things only change from one form to another and never go in or out of existence. This concept is known as mereology in philosophy. The alternative view is that the whole is more important than the constituents. This is illustrated by the example of mixing blue with yellow to create green. The parts cease to exist when the whole is created. Once you mix them, blue and yellow stop existing and a new color green is created. In the story this concept is questioned because green is created but blue still feels like blue. The story raises the question of which category the creation of green goes under but leaves the decision to the reader.
What makes ‘Little Blue’ who he is? This raises questions about the fourth concept the book deals with: identity. What makes a thing what it is (its identity) can be understood by thinking of how much of it you can change before it becomes something new. This issue is dealt with in Metaphysics. Philosophers have tried to understand how much a thing can change before it becomes something different. They have done this by dividing the properties of a thing into two categories: essential properties and accidental properties. Essential properties are those if changed the thing is no longer the same. Accidental properties are those that can be changed without changing the nature of the thing. While most philosophers agree on this division, the disagreement arises on what properties go under each category. For instance some people might think that the taste of an apple is an essential property. But rotten apples that don’t taste like fresh apples are still apples. Some people might think that the shape of an apple is what is essential, some apples are deformed but they are still apples. Therefore while philosophers agree that the two categories exist, it is hard if not impossible to know what property goes under which category. In the book the color of ‘little blue’ is what him ‘little blue’ but when he becomes green he still goes to the house that ‘little blue’ considers home. He looks different but feels the same. Once again the story raises questions about identity and leaves the decision to the reader.
Questions for Philosophical Discussion
by Hina Jawaid and Thomas Wartenberg
Little blue has many friends but his best friend is little yellow.
- Do you think that you need to become exactly like your best friend?
- Do friends have to have things in common? What things?
- Is it better for friends to be like each other or different from one another?
- Is having friends important to your being happy?
When “little blue” found ‘little yellow’ they hugged each other happily.
- What happened when ‘little blue’ hugged ‘little yellow’?
- Why didn’t papa and mama blue recognize ‘little blue’?
- When mama and papa blue think that green is not “little blue” were they right?
When mama and papa blue hugged “little yellow” they became green and then they realized what had happened.
- How did the parents realize what had happened?
- Can you think of a situation where things are not the way they look?
- There is a saying “seeing is believing” What do you think this means? Do you agree?
- Can you think of a situation when you thought a certain way but when you found out more about the thing you changed the way you thought about it?
Topic: Material Constitution
“Little blue” and “little yellow” were sad when their parents didn’t recognize them and they cried big blue and yellow tears. Now think of things like vegetable soup and paint
- Can you think of something that is made up of more than one thing?
- Can you separate the vegetables from the broth?
- Does something happen to the vegetables and the broth when you mix them to make soup?
- Can you separate yellow paint from blue paint when you mix the two to make green?
- Does something happen to the blue and yellow paint that you mix?
- What happened to ‘little blue’ and ‘little yellow’ when they became green?
- Do ‘little blue and ‘little green’ still exist when they become green or do they just change?
- ‘Little blue’ and ‘little yellow’ cried blue and yellow tears and become themselves again. What would happen if they were like paint and couldn’t separate themselves once they were mixed?
- What makes “green” what it is?
- Is “green” something totally new or is green a changed version of ‘little blue’ and ‘little yellow’?
They cried and cried until they were all tears and when they finally pulled themselves together they were ‘little blue’ and ‘little yellow’ again.
- Imagine that I paint a paper orange, is it still the same paper?
- Now imagine I burn that paper is it still the same paper?
- Can you think of something that changes its shape or form but is the same thing?
- Does the thing remain the same once it changes?
- Do you think people change as they get older?
- Do they become something new when they change?
- Now that ‘little blue’ had become green is ‘little blue’ different?