Recent Changes - Search:

The Fight

By Ginette Anfousse, New Canada Publications

Summary

The main Character, Jiji (a girl which is named in another story), communicates with the reader directly by breaking the fourth wall. At first the main character is embarrassed by her injury, a black eye she got in a fight. She then names the friends that could not have given her the injury, and then names the assailant, Cloclo, a young ruffian with a temper. The narrator then explains how she instigated the fight, and threw the first strike. The battle is described, and the lesson Cloclo learned is explained, but a twist occurs when it is revealed that Cloclo is the narrator’s friend. The Narrator then tells the audience that fighting isn’t nice.

Guidelines for Philosophical Discussion

By Matthew Clarke

Written by Ginette Anfousse, "The Fight" is a short story in the series staring the little girl named Jiji, and her misadventures. This particular entry in the series has the little girl talking about the fall-out she received from a fight. This story is full of excellent issues to have a philosophical discussion about fighting, including consequences such as; injury, shame and destruction, and the supposed reasons to fight, defense of property, and verbal insults.

The first and most important thing done is the demonstration one of the effects of fighting: Immediately after the story begins, the little girl, Jiji expresses a degree of shame, and the audience discovers her injury, and that it was received in a fight. After Jiji gives "injury" as a negative result of fighting, she lists her friends and the reasons she could not fight them. Then the antagonist, Cloclo is introduced and some of the reasons to fight are given to us. Reason's such as insults and the protection of property. After a brief discussion around the students's experiences with fighting, the teacher would then talk about Jiji's friends, and the reasons they did not fight with her. Then the students would be pressed to find out why Jiji decided to fight Cloclo. From there the teacher would ask them to find out when, if ever, it is okay to fight. If the students are efficient with there discussion, and there is still time left, then the kinds of fights that are had can be discussed. Can you fight with a friend? If so, is there a difference between a fight between friends and enemies? Finally, if friends can fight, what should happen to the friendship afterwords?

The second question set is designed to look into the nature of insults. In "The Fight," Jiji called Cloclo a liar and an IG-NO-RA-MUS. This verbal assault is what caused the fisticuffs, and the reasons for the insults is because Cloclo said something incorrect. After establishing this order of events, we will ask the students if they have ever made fun of someone, and why? After receiving answers and finding out why insults happen, probably along the lines of "I didn't like them" and "they were weird," the students would be asked if they have ever been "teased," and how that made them feel. After the teacher finds out why students "make fun" of each other, and how it feels, the teacher will ask when it is okay to make fun of each other, if it ever is. After finding out when, or if, it is okay to insult someone, and there is time left, the student will be asked to discover the difference between insults and gentle teasing, if it exists.

In Jiji's Fight with Cloclo, the safety of her stuffed aardvark, which she loved dearly, is brought into question. This happens after Cloclo is insulted until he looses emotional control, and decides to take out his frustration on Jiji's property. This scenario is what the facilitator will focus on when they begin discussing the nature of property. The facilitator will introduce this concept by asking if the children can think of something very special to them, and why it is important. After that, the facilitator should then find out if the children have ever lost something that they cared about; like a toy, or an article of clothing. these initial questions will help the children understand value and a sense of loss created by inanimate objects. Once the children have this understanding, the question of when it is appropriate, if ever, to defend property with violence. If the children manage to come to a consensus, than the apposing view can be dicussed. After mentioning the reason Cloclo tried to wreck Jiji's toy, the children can be asked: When, if ever is it okay to take away someones property, or have it destroyed? Hopefully, this third and final question set, will help children understand the nature of ownership and punishment,

These question sets are designed to encourage discussion in children in order to first find out what causes us to fight, what is gained and what is lost.They're are also questions designed to find out the reason's why people tease each other and when it is okay, and questions to help children understand the nature of property. Due to the amount of feedback each child is likely to have in any one of these areas of discussion, I would recommend having a chart to record what is discussed, this makes it easier for the facilitator to keep their place. Any of these discussions would be initiated by asking at why the Jiji fought, and teased, or why she needed to defend her property. The questions go on the ask examples of fighting, ownership, and insulting from their own life, from there we see what these examples have in common. These examples would be used to see what the reasons for insulting, valuing objects, and fighting are. From there we would get the children to discover the importance of being nonviolent (as necessary), polite (when needed), and understanding ownership; by getting them to analyze what violence, and crass behavior, has done to the little girl, Jiji's life.

There are some terms to keep in mind when discussing "The Fight" with young children, as they may be unfamiliar. It is important to tell the children that an Aardvark is a pig-like mammal, native to southern africa. It may also be warrented to mention that Pichou, the Aardvarks name, is her favourite toy and not a pet. The other term that probably needs explanation, is ignoramus, or IG-NO-RA-MUS as it is shown in the book. Let the kids know that an ignoramus is a fool, or someone lacking knowledge.

Questions for Philosophical Discussion

By Matthew Clarke

Fighting

This story is about a little girl and a fight she had.

  1. Have you ever gotten into a fight? What was it about?
  2. Why couldn’t the little girl have fought Pichou; the honest-to-goodness-baby-aardvark-who-really-eats-ants? Or Sophie? Phillipe? Why didn’t the little girl fight any of them? (put answers on chart)
  3. Is there any other reasons not to fight somebody? (put answers on chart)
  4. With all these reasons not to fight, why did Jiji and Cloclo fight? (put answers on chart)
  5. What other reasons can you think of to fight? What emotions do you think would cause someone to fight? (Put answers on chart)
  6. Is it ever okay to fight? If so, when?
  7. It is revealed that Jiji and Cloclo are friends, can someone you fight be your friend? Why or why not?
  8. Is fighting a friend different from fighting an enemy?
  9. When the fight is over, can the person you fought be a friend? Why or why not?

Insults

You're a liar, and an IG-NO-RA-MUS.

  1. Has anyone here ever teased someone? what sort of things did you say? (Put answers on chart)
  2. Why do we tease each other and call each other names? (Put answers on chart)
  3. How do you feel when you tease someone?
  4. Has Anyone here ever been teased, or made fun of? What did they say? (put answers on chart)
  5. How did you feel after they teased you? (Put answers on chart)
  6. Is it ever okay to make fun of someone? If so, when is it okay?
  7. Can you tease someone and still be friends? If so, why is it different when someone else says it?
  8. Is it okay to fight someone for saying something mean?

Property

Naturally I had to defend my little Pichou.

  1. Does anybody here have something that is important to them? Why is it so special? (Put answers on chart)
  2. Have you ever lost something that was important to you? Or had something stolen? How did you feel? (Put answers on chart)
  3. Is it ever okay to fight to protect an object? If so when?
  4. Has Anyone here ever been teased, like Cloclo?
  5. When, if ever, is it okay, to take away someones things?
  6. Is it ever okay to have someones things destroyed? If so, when?

This book module deals with ethics. You can buy this book on Amazon.

This website was developed with the assistance of the Squire Family Foundation.